Warrington Town's record in Northern Premier League Cup The table below shows the club's league record, including top appearance maker and goalscorer each season (league games only). Please be aware that appearance data is incomplete prior to 1999.
| Date | Opponent | Comp | Att |
Result | Warrington Scorers | | | 27/10/1990 | Harrogate Town (H) | NPL C | 122 | 0-1 | | Details |
| 22/10/1991 | Curzon Ashton (H) | NPL C | 130 | 0-0 | | Details |
| 11/11/1991 | Curzon Ashton (A) | NPL C | 114 | 0-1 | | Details |
| 24/10/1992 | Worksop (A) | NPL C | | 3-1 | Watson (2 goals), Warder | Details |
| 12/12/1992 | Bishop Auckland (H) | NPL C | | 1-0 | McNally | Details |
| 03/02/1993 | Whitley Bay (H) | NPL C | | 1-1 | Watson | Details |
| 09/03/1993 | Whitley Bay (A) | NPL C | | 3-1aet | Watson (2 goals), Dunn | Details |
| 16/03/1993 | Matlock Town (A) | NPL C | 336 | 2-1 | Dunn, McNally | Details |
| 29/03/1993 | Gretna (H) | NPL C | | 3-2 | Dunn, McDonald, Saunders | Details |
| 06/04/1993 | Gretna (A) | NPL C | | 1-1 | Saunders | Details |
| 27/04/1993 | Winsford United (N) | NPL C | 2043 | 1-1^ | McNally (70) | Details |
| 23/10/1993 | Lancaster City (A) | NPL C | 88 | 1-1 | Dunn (72) | Details |
| 17/11/1993 | Lancaster City (H) | NPL C | | 2-4 | Knop (2 goals) | Details |
| 04/10/1994 | Curzon Ashton (H) | NPL C | 118 | 3-0 | McDonald (2 goals), Soley | Details |
| 08/11/1994 | Caernarfon Town (H) | NPL C | 153 | 1-1 | Lee (80) | Details |
| 16/11/1994 | Caernarfon Town (A) | NPL C | 196 | 1-0 | Heavey | Details |
| 19/11/1994 | Barrow (H) | NPL C | 205 | 2-1 | Own Goal, Heavey | Details |
| 14/02/1995 | Chorley (H) | NPL C | | 0-0 | | Details |
| 21/02/1995 | Chorley (A) | NPL C | | 0-2 | | Details |
| 03/10/1995 | Ashton United (H) | NPL C | | 1-2 | Heavey | Details |
| 02/10/1996 | Droylsden (A) | NPL C | | 2-1 | Sutcliffe (2 goals) | Details |
| 19/11/1996 | Flixton (A) | NPL C | | 0-2 | | Details |
| 26/10/2004 | Colwyn Bay (A) | NPL C | 128 | 4-1 | Nestor, Riley, Mitchell, Own Goal | Details |
| 16/11/2004 | Radcliffe (H) | NPL C | 80 | 3-4 | Salt, Dyson (2 goals) | Details |
| 01/11/2005 | Colwyn Bay (A) | NPL C | 178 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 07/01/2006 | Woodley Sports (H) | NPL C | 79 | 0-1 | | Details |
| 31/10/2006 | Colwyn Bay (A) | NPL C | 141 | 3-1aet | Mitchell (86, 105), Connell (118) | Details |
| 21/11/2006 | Woodley Sports (A) | NPL C | 55 | 0-3 | | Details |
| 16/10/2007 | Rossendale (H) | NPL C | 85 | 2-0 | Mitchell (51), Robinson (76) | Details |
| 20/11/2007 | Fleetwood Town (A) | NPL C | 224 | 3-7 | Elder, Mitchell (pen), Mitchell | Details |
| 30/09/2008 | Colwyn Bay (H) | NPL C | 101 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 22/09/2009 | Leigh Genesis (A) | NPL C | 139 | 1-6 | Evans (1) | Details |
| 12/10/2010 | Witton Albion (H) | NPL C | 119 | 2-4 | Gahgan, Salmon | Details |
| 06/09/2011 | Cammell Laird (H) | NPL C | 55 | 4-2aet | Henders (14), McGowan (60, 119), Gahgan (112) | Details |
| 18/10/2011 | Prescot Cables (A) | NPL C | 101 | 2-1 | Thompson (35, 59) | Details |
| 15/11/2011 | Newcastle Town (A) | NPL C | 69 | 0-2aet | | Details |
| 27/11/2012 | Mossley (A) | NPL C | 95 | 7-1 | Doran Ph, Mooney, Townson (4 goals), Miles | Details |
| 18/12/2012 | Trafford (A) | NPL C | 126 | 2-3 | Mooney, Ruane | Details |
| 12/11/2013 | Burscough (A) | NPL C | 124 | 0-3 | | Details |
| 18/11/2014 | Radcliffe (A) | NPL C | 69 | 3-0 | Mannix, Metcalfe, Foster | Details |
| 02/12/2014 | Workington (A) | NPL C | 237 | 3-2 | Ruane, Colbeck (2 goals) | Details |
| 13/01/2015 | Rushall Olympic (A) | NPL C | 101 | 3-0 | McCarten, Burke, Own Goal | Details |
| 25/02/2015 | Leek Town (A) | NPL C | 111 | 1-0 | Metcalfe (78) | Details |
| 24/03/2015 | Ilkeston (H) | NPL C | 356 | 3-0 | Metcalfe (17), Tames (27), Wharton (35) | Details |
| 30/04/2015 | Farsley Celtic (A) | NPL C | 731 | 0-0aet* | | Details |
| 01/12/2015 | Ramsbottom United (A) | NPL C | 104 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 15/11/2016 | Ashton United (A) | NPL C | 83 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 17/10/2017 | Colwyn Bay (A) | NPL C | 133 | 3-2 | Hughes, Sanogo (2 goals, 1 pen) | Details |
| 20/02/2018 | Lancaster City (H) | NPL C | 108 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 18/09/2018 | Runcorn Linnets (A) | NPL C | 228 | 1-1aet^ | Evans (35) | Details |
| 11/11/2019 | Kidsgrove Athletic (A) | NPL C | 99 | 2-2^ | Jerbin (28), Murray (57) | Details |
* = Won on penalties
^ = Lost on penalties |
