Warrington Town's record in FA Cup The table below shows the club's league record, including top appearance maker and goalscorer each season (league games only). Please be aware that appearance data is incomplete prior to 1999.
| Date | Opponent | Comp | Att |
Result | Warrington Scorers | | | 08/09/1956 | Winsford United (H) | FAC | 700 | 4-5 | Tipping, Green (2 goals), Foster | Details |
| 07/09/1957 | Ellesmere Port Town (A) | FAC | | 0-3 | | Details |
| 20/09/1958 | Witton Albion (A) | FAC | 1550 | 4-2 | Berrington (3 goals), Hayes | Details |
| 04/10/1958 | Ellesmere Port (H) | FAC | 1905 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 05/09/1959 | Congleton (H) | FAC | | 0-3 | | Details |
| 03/09/1983 | Stalybridge Celtic (H) | FAC | | 0-3 | | Details |
| 24/08/1985 | Eastwood Town (H) | FAC | | 3-1 | Stokes, Kinsey, Hughes | Details |
| 07/09/1985 | Formby (H) | FAC | | 1-3 | Stokes | Details |
| 13/09/1986 | Penrith (H) | FAC | | 0-2 | | Details |
| 29/08/1987 | Burscough (A) | FAC | | 2-1 | Layhe, Kinsey | Details |
| 12/09/1987 | Northwich Victoria (H) | FAC | 430 | 1-1 | O'Neill | Details |
| 16/09/1987 | Northwich Victoria (A) | FAC | 645 | 1-5aet | O'Neill | Details |
| 03/09/1988 | Curzon Ashton (H) | FAC | | 3-2 | Hodge (2 goals), Lake | Details |
| 17/09/1988 | Bilston Town (A) | FAC | | 0-0 | | Details |
| 20/09/1988 | Bilston Town (H) | FAC | | 3-2 | Whalley, Hughes, Lake | Details |
| 01/10/1988 | Rhyl (A) | FAC | | 1-1 | Hodge | Details |
| 04/10/1988 | Rhyl (H) | FAC | | 2-0 | Walker, Lake | Details |
| 15/10/1988 | Leek Town (H) | FAC | 378 | 1-2 | Hodge | Details |
| 02/09/1989 | Mile Oak Rovers (A) | FAC | | 2-1 | Whalley, Hodge | Details |
| 16/09/1989 | North Ferriby Utd (H) | FAC | | 1-0 | Cook | Details |
| 30/09/1989 | Witton Albion (A) | FAC | 701 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 01/09/1990 | Salford City (A) | FAC | 121 | 3-0 | Cook, Harvey (2 goals) | Details |
| 15/09/1990 | South Liverpool (A) | FAC | 237 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 31/08/1991 | Salford City (A) | FAC | 113 | 0-0 | | Details |
| 03/09/1991 | Salford City (H) | FAC | 194 | 1-0 | Dunn | Details |
| 14/09/1991 | Hyde United (H) | FAC | 290 | 1-0 | Meachin | Details |
| 28/09/1991 | Marine (H) | FAC | 317 | 0-0 | | Details |
| 01/10/1991 | Marine (A) | FAC | 217 | 0-1 | | Details |
| 29/08/1992 | Skelmersdale United (H) | FAC | | 6-1 | McDonald (4 goals), Watson, Beck | Details |
| 12/09/1992 | Harrogate Town (A) | FAC | | 2-1 | McNally, Whalley | Details |
| 26/09/1992 | Stalybridge Celtic (H) | FAC | | 0-3 | | Details |
| 28/08/1993 | Bradford PA (H) | FAC | 248 | 5-0 | McDonald (2 goals), Saunders (2 goals), Cook | Details |
| 11/09/1993 | Matlock Town (H) | FAC | 302 | 3-0 | McDonald (8, 60), Finley (85) | Details |
| 25/09/1993 | Clitheroe (H) | FAC | | 2-2 | Finley, McDonald | Details |
| 28/09/1993 | Clitheroe (A) | FAC | | 2-0 | Nicely, O'Connor | Details |
| 09/10/1993 | Stalybridge Celtic (H) | FAC | 654 | 0-1 | | Details |
| 10/09/1994 | St Helens Town (A) | FAC | 185 | 4-0 | Soley (3, 28), Lee (73), McDonald (76) | Details |
| 24/09/1994 | Sheffield (H) | FAC | 170 | 2-1 | Warder, McDonald | Details |
| 08/10/1994 | Frickley Athletic (H) | FAC | 252 | 2-0 | McDonald, Lee | Details |
| 22/10/1994 | Hyde United (A) | FAC | 658 | 1-1 | Heavey (90) | Details |
| 26/10/1994 | Hyde United (H) | FAC | 1061 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 09/09/1995 | Trafford (H) | FAC | | 2-2 | O'Callaghan (2 goals) | Details |
| 12/09/1995 | Trafford (A) | FAC | | 3-4 | Heavey (pen), O'Callaghan, Brady | Details |
| 14/09/1996 | Hyde United (H) | FAC | | 0-1 | | Details |
| 30/08/1997 | Peterlee Newtown (A) | FAC | | 3-1 | McGhee, Birch, Vincent | Details |
| 13/09/1997 | RTM Newcastle (H) | FAC | | 1-2 | McDonald (6) | Details |
| 05/09/1998 | Oldham Town (A) | FAC | | 2-0 | Bold, Whitehead | Details |
| 19/09/1998 | North Ferriby Utd (H) | FAC | | 0-4 | | Details |
| 21/08/1999 | Cheadle Town (A) | FAC | 82 | 3-0 | Holden, Bushell, Lee | Details |
| 04/09/1999 | Radcliffe (A) | FAC | 168 | 1-8 | Tickle | Details |
| 02/09/2000 | Denaby United (A) | FAC | 120 | 2-0 | Holden, Barr | Details |
| 16/09/2000 | Clitheroe (H) | FAC | 119 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 01/09/2001 | Ashington (H) | FAC | 47 | 0-0 | | Details |
| 04/09/2001 | Ashington (A) | FAC | 237 | 0-3 | | Details |
| 31/08/2002 | Esh Winning (H) | FAC | 110 | 2-2 | Holden (2 goals) | Details |
| 04/09/2002 | Esh Winning (A) | FAC | 120 | 1-3aet | Latham | Details |
| 23/08/2003 | Eccleshill United (A) | FAC | 90 | 2-1 | Mitchell, Mitchell | Details |
| 30/08/2003 | Yorkshire Amateur (H) | FAC | 92 | 1-0 | Bermingham | Details |
| 13/09/2003 | North Ferriby Utd (H) | FAC | 107 | 6-1 | Bermingham, Mitchell (3 goals), Moore, Tyrell | Details |
| 27/09/2003 | Spennymoor United (A) | FAC | 202 | 2-0 | Bermingham, Mitchell | Details |
| 11/10/2003 | Whitby Town (H) | FAC | 253 | 0-0 | | Details |
| 15/10/2003 | Whitby Town (A) | FAC | 384 | 1-2 | Mitchell | Details |
| 04/09/2004 | Pontefract Collieries (H) | FAC | 132 | 3-0 | Farrell, Dyson (2 goals) | Details |
| 18/09/2004 | Horden Colliery Welfare (A) | FAC | 77 | 1-1 | Moores | Details |
| 21/09/2004 | Horden Colliery Welfare (A) | FAC | 124 | 1-2 | Moores | Details |
| 27/08/2005 | Penrith (H) | FAC | 84 | 2-2 | Mitchell, Mitchell | Details |
| 30/08/2005 | Penrith (A) | FAC | 118 | 2-1aet | Randles, McNally | Details |
| 11/09/2005 | Gateshead (A) | FAC | 235 | 0-4 | | Details |
| 02/09/2006 | Yorkshire Amateur (A) | FAC | 70 | 5-1 | Evans (2 goals, 1 pen), Burton (3 goals, 1 pen) | Details |
| 16/09/2006 | Long Eaton United (A) | FAC | 86 | 3-1 | Fitzsimmons (7), Baker (14), Tickle (45) | Details |
| 30/09/2006 | Kendal Town (A) | FAC | 245 | 1-1 | Towey (89) | Details |
| 03/10/2006 | Kendal Town (H) | FAC | 132 | 3-2aet | Mitchell (38, 67), Latham (117) | Details |
| 14/10/2006 | Fleetwood Town (A) | FAC | 567 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 01/09/2007 | Chorley (A) | FAC | 322 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 30/08/2008 | Nostell MW (H) | FAC | 132 | 0-0 | | Details |
| 02/09/2008 | Nostell MW (A) | FAC | 165 | 2-1 | Hadland (37), Towey (88) | Details |
| 13/09/2008 | Winterton Rangers (A) | FAC | 100 | 2-4 | Smith, Rendell | Details |
| 28/08/2009 | Leigh Genesis (H) | FAC | 167 | 1-0 | Chetcuti | Details |
| 12/09/2009 | Nantwich Town (H) | FAC | 204 | 1-0 | McCarthy | Details |
| 26/09/2009 | Radcliffe (H) | FAC | 234 | 1-1 | Gahgan (pen) | Details |
| 29/09/2009 | Radcliffe (A) | FAC | 169 | 1-3 | Evans | Details |
| 28/08/2010 | Bootle (A) | FAC | 223 | 2-1 | Evans, Salmon | Details |
| 11/09/2010 | Parkgate (A) | FAC | 122 | 3-1 | Corrigan (2 goals, 1 pen), Gahgan | Details |
| 25/09/2010 | Bamber Bridge (A) | FAC | 223 | 1-1 | Evans | Details |
| 28/09/2010 | Bamber Bridge (H) | FAC | 236 | 4-2 | Hardwick (2 goals), Evans, Duffy | Details |
| 09/10/2010 | Stalybridge Celtic (H) | FAC | 429 | 1-3 | Hardwick (25) | Details |
| 03/09/2011 | Prescot Cables (A) | FAC | 263 | 2-0 | Hickey (79), Gahgan (90) | Details |
| 20/09/2011 | Bamber Bridge (A) | FAC | 159 | 4-0 | Henders (30), Finley (33), Thompson (58 pen, 78) | Details |
| 01/10/2011 | Bradford PA (A) | FAC | 268 | 1-3 | Hickey (3 pen) | Details |
| 25/08/2012 | Atherton LR (A) | FAC | 68 | 3-0 | Hardwick, Townson, Driscoll | Details |
| 08/09/2012 | Maine Road (H) | FAC | 224 | 1-0 | Shipton | Details |
| 22/09/2012 | Colwyn Bay (A) | FAC | 245 | 2-3 | Townson, McEvilly | Details |
| 31/08/2013 | Winsford United (H) | FAC | 151 | 5-0 | Metcalfe, McCarten (2 goals), Kilheeney, Dawson | Details |
| 14/09/2013 | New Mills (H) | FAC | 130 | 0-0 | | Details |
| 16/09/2013 | New Mills (A) | FAC | 114 | 1-0 | McCarten | Details |
| 28/09/2013 | Ossett Town (A) | FAC | 139 | 1-1 | Newby | Details |
| 01/10/2013 | Ossett Town (H) | FAC | 133 | 1-3aet | Gahgan | Details |
| 30/08/2014 | Barton T Old Boys (H) | FAC | 114 | 4-1 | Metcalfe (3 goals), Gahgan | Details |
| 13/09/2014 | Trafford (H) | FAC | 127 | 1-0 | Metcalfe | Details |
| 27/09/2014 | Sheffield (H) | FAC | 190 | 0-0 | | Details |
| 30/09/2014 | Sheffield (A) | FAC | 176 | 3-1 | Foster (2 goals), Metcalfe | Details |
| 11/10/2014 | Colwyn Bay (A) | FAC | 453 | 1-1 | Gahgan (90) | Details |
| 14/10/2014 | Colwyn Bay (H) | FAC | 284 | 1-0 | Burke | Details |
| 25/10/2014 | North Ferriby Utd (H) | FAC | 691 | 1-0 | Field | Details |
| 07/11/2014 | Exeter City (H) | FAC | 2400 | 1-0 | Robinson (7) | Details |
| 07/12/2014 | Gateshead (A) | FAC | 2874 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 29/08/2015 | Abbey Hey (A) | FAC | 152 | 2-3 | Robinson, Gillespie | Details |
| 03/09/2016 | Workington (A) | FAC | 448 | 0-3 | | Details |
| 02/09/2017 | Grimsby Borough (H) | FAC | 297 | 1-0 | Sanogo | Details |
| 16/09/2017 | Hyde United (H) | FAC | 429 | 1-1 | Kinsella (69) | Details |
| 19/09/2017 | Hyde United (A) | FAC | 433 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 08/09/2018 | Burscough (H) | FAC | 240 | 4-0 | Mackreth, Gray (2 goals), Brodie | Details |
| 22/09/2018 | Consett (A) | FAC | 451 | 3-3 | Dixon (21), Vassallo (45), Gray (66) | Details |
| 25/09/2018 | Consett (H) | FAC | 312 | 2-0 | Gray, Dixon | Details |
| 06/10/2018 | AFC Telford United (H) | FAC | 543 | 2-1 | Dixon, Garrity | Details |
| 20/10/2018 | FC Halifax Town (H) | FAC | 929 | 2-2 | Garrity, Gray | Details |
| 23/10/2018 | FC Halifax Town (A) | FAC | 844 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 07/09/2019 | City of Liverpool (H) | FAC | 602 | 2-2 | Dixon (44), Amis (90) | Details |
| 10/09/2019 | City of Liverpool (A) | FAC | 1099 | 4-0 | Byrne (1), Roberts (27), Garrity (45), Gray (71) | Details |
| 21/09/2019 | FC United of Manchester (A) | FAC | 1263 | 2-1 | Duggan (28), Roberts (70) | Details |
| 05/10/2019 | Brackley Town (A) | FAC | 452 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 22/09/2020 | South Shields (H) | FAC | 426 | 0-0^ | | Details |
| 04/09/2021 | Kendal Town (A) | FAC | 192 | 1-0 | Grivosti (51) | Details |
| 18/09/2021 | Marine (A) | FAC | 1003 | 0-3 | | Details |
| 03/09/2022 | Morpeth Town (A) | FAC | 339 | 2-2 | Duffy (19), Mols (37) | Details |
| 06/09/2022 | Morpeth Town (H) | FAC | 445 | 2-1 | Hannigan (42), Gumbs (63) | Details |
| 18/09/2022 | Hyde United (A) | FAC | 511 | 0-1 | | Details |
| 16/09/2023 | Curzon Ashton (H) | FAC | 733 | 2-3 | Mottley-Henry (27), Dixon (32) | Details |
| 14/09/2024 | Radcliffe (H) | FAC | 902 | 1-2 | Woods (45) | Details |
| 30/08/2025 | Bamber Bridge (H) | FAC | 491 | 0-3 | | Details |
* = Won on penalties
^ = Lost on penalties |
