Warrington Town's record in FA Trophy The table below shows the club's league record, including top appearance maker and goalscorer each season (league games only). Please be aware that appearance data is incomplete prior to 1999.
| Date | Opponent | Comp | Att |
Result | Warrington Scorers | | | 21/09/1991 | Goole Town (A) | FAT | | 1-2 | Dunn | Details |
| 17/10/1992 | Shepshed Albion (H) | FAT | | 3-0 | Watson (3 goals) | Details |
| 28/11/1992 | Stockton (H) | FAT | | 5-2 | Dunn (2 goals), McDonald, Watson, McNally | Details |
| 09/01/1993 | Guisborough Town (H) | FAT | | 2-1 | McDonald, Warder | Details |
| 30/01/1993 | Bishop Auckland (A) | FAT | | 1-0 | Dunn | Details |
| 20/02/1993 | Merthyr Tydfil (A) | FAT | | 1-1 | Watson | Details |
| 23/02/1993 | Merthyr Tydfil (H) | FAT | 1447 | 3-2 | Watson, Dunn, McDonald | Details |
| 13/03/1993 | Sutton United (A) | FAT | 1547 | 1-2 | Dunn | Details |
| 22/01/1994 | Gretna (A) | FAT | 102 | 1-1 | Knop | Details |
| 25/01/1994 | Gretna (H) | FAT | | 2-3 | Finley, Nicely | Details |
| 26/11/1994 | Colwyn Bay (H) | FAT | 208 | 1-1 | Heavey | Details |
| 29/11/1994 | Colwyn Bay (A) | FAT | 434 | 0-3 | | Details |
| 14/10/1995 | Racing Club Warwick (A) | FAT | | 0-1 | | Details |
| 19/10/1996 | Lancaster City (H) | FAT | | 0-2 | | Details |
| 09/10/2004 | Ossett Albion (H) | FAT | 109 | 2-3 | Latham, Heverin | Details |
| 15/10/2005 | Frickley Athletic (H) | FAT | 132 | 1-1 | Howard (69) | Details |
| 18/10/2005 | Frickley Athletic (A) | FAT | 265 | 1-1aet* | Latham | Details |
| 12/11/2005 | Bridlington (A) | FAT | 192 | 2-2 | Featherstone, Lacken | Details |
| 15/11/2005 | Bridlington (H) | FAT | 110 | 1-0 | Featherstone | Details |
| 26/11/2005 | Kidsgrove Athletic (H) | FAT | 121 | 4-0 | Mitchell, Featherstone, Mitchell (2 goals) | Details |
| 17/12/2005 | Blyth Spartans (H) | FAT | 251 | 1-2 | Tickle | Details |
| 07/10/2006 | Wakefield (H) | FAT | 104 | 3-2 | Hannon (24, 72), Burton (90 pen) | Details |
| 21/10/2006 | Clitheroe (H) | FAT | 132 | 0-1 | | Details |
| 06/10/2007 | Rossendale (H) | FAT | 114 | 3-2 | Smith (35 pen), Ellison (39, 69) | Details |
| 20/10/2007 | Romulus (A) | FAT | 80 | 1-0 | Thompson | Details |
| 03/11/2007 | Ossett Town (A) | FAT | 102 | 0-3 | | Details |
| 04/10/2008 | Chorley (A) | FAT | 209 | 0-0 | | Details |
| 07/10/2008 | Chorley (H) | FAT | 128 | 3-0 | Hadland, Lamb (2 goals) | Details |
| 18/10/2008 | Matlock Town (A) | FAT | 242 | 1-0 | Rendell (74) | Details |
| 02/11/2008 | Romulus (A) | FAT | 115 | 2-2 | Towey, Daniels | Details |
| 04/11/2008 | Romulus (H) | FAT | 80 | 3-1aet | Gahgan, Daniels, Tickle | Details |
| 22/11/2008 | Nantwich Town (H) | FAT | 232 | 0-1 | | Details |
| 03/10/2009 | Sheffield (H) | FAT | 142 | 5-2 | Gahgan (3 goals, 2 pens), McCarthy, Grogan | Details |
| 17/10/2009 | Whitby Town (A) | FAT | 274 | 2-5 | McCarthy (2 goals) | Details |
| 02/10/2010 | Shepshed Dynamo (A) | FAT | 123 | 1-2 | Gahgan | Details |
| 08/10/2011 | Sheffield (A) | FAT | 213 | 2-2 | Hickey (18, 65) | Details |
| 11/10/2011 | Sheffield (H) | FAT | 105 | 2-3 | Collins (53), Hickey (57) | Details |
| 15/09/2012 | Leek Town (H) | FAT | 172 | 1-2 | Townson | Details |
| 05/10/2013 | Ramsbottom United (H) | FAT | 103 | 1-2 | Dawson | Details |
| 18/10/2014 | Mossley (H) | FAT | 131 | 1-2 | Foster | Details |
| 03/10/2015 | Ossett Town (A) | FAT | 101 | 2-1 | Edwards, Deegan | Details |
| 31/10/2015 | Brighouse Town (H) | FAT | 235 | 2-0 | Kilheeney, McCarten | Details |
| 14/11/2015 | Basford United (H) | FAT | 202 | 3-0 | Kilheeney (3 goals) | Details |
| 28/11/2015 | AFC Fylde (H) | FAT | 297 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 29/10/2016 | Nantwich Town (H) | FAT | 274 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 28/10/2017 | Bamber Bridge (H) | FAT | 239 | 2-1 | McDonald (2 goals) | Details |
| 11/11/2017 | Ashton United (H) | FAT | 313 | 1-1 | Sanogo (68) | Details |
| 14/11/2017 | Ashton United (A) | FAT | 163 | 2-2aet* | McDonald (2 goals) | Details |
| 25/11/2017 | Tamworth (A) | FAT | 468 | 2-2 | Vassallo, McDonald | Details |
| 28/11/2017 | Tamworth (H) | FAT | 223 | 3-0 | McDonald (2 goals), Gray | Details |
| 16/12/2017 | Altrincham (H) | FAT | 545 | 0-0 | | Details |
| 19/12/2017 | Altrincham (A) | FAT | 453 | 2-1 | Goulding, McDonald | Details |
| 13/01/2018 | Ebbsfleet United (A) | FAT | 911 | 1-1 | Kinsella | Details |
| 16/01/2018 | Ebbsfleet United (H) | FAT | 334 | 2-0 | McDonald, Gray | Details |
| 03/02/2018 | Wealdstone (A) | FAT | 601 | 1-2 | Piggott (82) | Details |
| 27/10/2018 | Prescot Cables (H) | FAT | 316 | 0-1 | | Details |
| 26/10/2019 | Ashton United (H) | FAT | 327 | 0-1 | | Details |
| 31/10/2020 | Lancaster City (H) | FAT | 406 | 1-1* | Buckley (28) | Details |
| 08/12/2020 | Marske United (A) | FAT | | 1-3 | Gumbs (27) | Details |
| 30/10/2021 | Hebburn Town (A) | FAT | 267 | 2-0 | Mackreth (58), Mols (76) | Details |
| 13/11/2021 | Chasetown (H) | FAT | 603 | 2-0 | Grivosti (1), Duffy (76) | Details |
| 27/11/2021 | Morpeth Town (H) | FAT | 491 | 1-1^ | McDonald (38) | Details |
| 08/10/2022 | Hebburn Town (A) | FAT | 248 | 2-1 | Amis (59), Williams (90 pen) | Details |
| 29/10/2022 | South Shields (H) | FAT | 577 | 3-1 | Hannigan (31), Woods (37, 59) | Details |
| 19/11/2022 | Guiseley (H) | FAT | 560 | 0-1 | | Details |
| 18/11/2023 | Blyth Spartans (H) | FAT | 930 | 1-3 | Own Goal (70) | Details |
| 16/11/2024 | Southport (A) | FAT | 1166 | 0-3 | | Details |
| 04/10/2025 | Hyde United (A) | FAT | 396 | 0-1 | | Details |
* = Won on penalties
^ = Lost on penalties |
